CineMonth – Cuban Cinema – Reviews 1
There are films that belong so completely to a historical moment that they risk becoming documents of that moment rather than living works of cinema. Tomás Gutiérrez Alea’s Memories of Underdevelopment does the opposite. Made in 1968 and set during the first years after the Cuban Revolution, the film remains alive because it does not reduce history to slogans or divide people neatly between heroes and enemies. Instead, it places one deeply contradictory man at the center of a country undergoing enormous transformation and asks what happens when society begins moving forward while an individual remains emotionally and morally trapped in the world that is disappearing.
Sergio, played with extraordinary intelligence by Sergio Corrieri, belongs to the Cuban bourgeoisie that had benefited from the social order existing before the Revolution. His wife, friends and many people from his class have left Cuba, primarily for the United States, but Sergio decides to remain in Havana. His decision initially gives him the appearance of someone independent enough to resist the panic of his social circle, yet Gutiérrez Alea gradually reveals that staying does not mean participating. Sergio remains physically in Cuba while emotionally standing outside almost everything happening around him.
This is what makes him such a fascinating protagonist. He is not a Batista supporter longing openly for the return of the old order, nor is he a committed revolutionary trying to build the new society. He prefers the position of observer because observation allows him to feel intellectually superior without accepting responsibility for anything. He watches other people, analyzes their behavior and repeatedly concludes that almost everyone around him is underdeveloped, yet the deeper the film enters his consciousness, the clearer it becomes that the most profound underdevelopment may exist within Sergio himself.
The title therefore works on several levels. Underdevelopment can refer to economic conditions, the relationship between wealthy and poorer nations, or the historical situation of countries such as Cuba emerging from colonialism and foreign economic domination. Sergio uses the idea differently, however, treating it almost as a psychological judgment on the people surrounding him. He sees Cuban society as culturally immature and believes himself to be above it because he reads books, appreciates European culture and considers himself more sophisticated than ordinary people. Gutiérrez Alea slowly turns this arrogance against him.
Sergio may possess education, but education has not taught him how to connect with other human beings. He may understand European literature, but he understands very little about the emotional lives of the women around him. He can analyze political events while remaining incapable of choosing a position that requires sacrifice. His supposed sophistication becomes a shelter protecting him from engagement.

This is one of the film’s great achievements because Gutiérrez Alea never needs to announce that Sergio is wrong. He allows Sergio to expose himself through his own thoughts and behavior. The audience spends so much time inside his mind that we begin by sharing something of his confidence, only gradually recognizing how unreliable that confidence is.
The structure of the film is essential to this experience. Memories of Underdevelopment does not proceed like a conventional drama in which one event leads clearly to another. Fictional scenes are interrupted by photographs, documentary material, political events, memories and images of Havana. Sergio’s thoughts move between past and present, while the history unfolding around him constantly enters the private world he is trying to preserve. The result is a film in which personal memory and national history become inseparable.
The Revolution is not represented simply through speeches or scenes of political activity. It is visible in apartments that have been abandoned, in people leaving for Miami, in new social relationships and in the changing streets of Havana. Sergio cannot escape history because it has entered every part of daily life.
This was one of the remarkable qualities of the early revolutionary Cuban cinema. Filmmakers understood that a revolution does not exist only at the level of government. It changes friendships, marriages, property, work and the way people imagine their future. Gutiérrez Alea brings these enormous transformations down to the scale of one apartment and one man wandering through the city.
Sergio’s apartment becomes a particularly revealing space. It contains the remnants of his earlier bourgeois life, including books, possessions and memories of the wife who has left. From this protected environment, he can look down on Havana almost as if the city were an object created for his observation. There is something very important in the way he looks.
Sergio is constantly turning other people into objects of analysis, especially women. He observes them, compares them, judges their intelligence and imagines himself capable of understanding them more completely than they understand themselves. His relationship with Elena, played by Daisy Granados, makes this attitude particularly clear.

Elena comes from a very different social and educational background, and Sergio becomes attracted to her partly because he considers her simple. Instead of attempting to understand who she actually is, he repeatedly treats her as material for his own intellectual and sexual curiosity.
The relationship gradually exposes one of Sergio’s deepest contradictions. He criticizes the underdevelopment he believes he sees in others while using his own class and education to establish power over someone younger and less socially privileged.
Gutiérrez Alea does not need to explain this contradiction because Corrieri’s performance makes it visible. Sergio’s charm and intelligence remain present, but they gradually begin to feel like weapons he uses to protect himself from emotional responsibility.
The women in his memories are treated similarly. His former wife exists partly through fragments of remembered conversations and recorded material, and Sergio continually interprets her through his own assumptions. He sees himself as the thoughtful partner surrounded by women incapable of reaching his level, but the film repeatedly gives us reasons to question whether the problem may be his inability to see anyone except through himself.
This psychological dimension prevents the film from becoming a simple political portrait. Sergio’s alienation existed before the Revolution, even if the Revolution makes it impossible for him to hide it as easily.
The old society had given people like Sergio a secure social position. Wealth, class and cultural status could provide the appearance of purpose even when little existed underneath. The Revolution removes much of that structure, leaving Sergio with himself. What remains is not very impressive.

This is why I see Memories of Underdevelopment as one of the strongest films made in support of revolutionary change without needing to romanticize every individual living inside the new society. Gutiérrez Alea understands that the Revolution has created possibilities, but he is more interested in what people do with those possibilities.
Sergio has the opportunity to participate in the transformation of his country. He chooses distance. That choice becomes the film’s central moral problem. The historical context makes this especially powerful. The events surrounding Sergio include the Bay of Pigs invasion and the growing confrontation with the United States that would culminate in the Cuban Missile Crisis. Cuba is living through one of the most dangerous periods in its history, having broken with a powerful neighbor that had exercised enormous political, economic and cultural influence over the island.
Sergio watches these events while maintaining the emotional posture of someone who believes history is occurring around him rather than to him. This position eventually becomes impossible. A person may attempt to remain neutral, but neutrality itself becomes a choice when society is confronting fundamental questions about sovereignty and independence.
Gutiérrez Alea never turns Sergio into a cartoon of bourgeois selfishness. That would make the film easier politically but much weaker dramatically. Sergio is intelligent enough to recognize genuine contradictions, and some of his observations about Cuban society are perceptive. The problem is not that he sees nothing. The problem is that seeing has become a substitute for acting. This distinction gives the film much of its intellectual power.
There are people in every society who confuse criticism with participation. They believe that identifying the weaknesses of everyone else proves their own independence, yet their refusal to commit themselves can become another form of privilege. Sergio belongs to this type. He has enough economic security to observe a revolution as an intellectual problem while other people experience it as a transformation of their actual lives.

The film’s mixture of documentary and fiction continually reminds us of this difference. Real historical images enter Sergio’s private world and challenge his attempts to turn everything into personal reflection. The public and private cannot be separated because the transformation of Cuba is happening on both levels at once.
Nelson Rodríguez’s editing is crucial to creating this effect. The film moves between different types of material without attempting to make the transitions invisible. Rather than disguising the fact that photographs, newsreels and fictional scenes have different textures, the editing allows those differences to collide. This approach gives the film an extraordinary rhythm.
Havana becomes simultaneously a real city, Sergio’s memory of the city and a historical space undergoing change. Ramón F. Suárez’s black-and-white cinematography reinforces this sense of uncertainty. The city can appear beautiful and strangely empty, familiar and transformed at the same time. Gutiérrez Alea photographs Havana with affection, but he never turns it into a postcard.
The Cuba we see is alive with transition. Old social structures are disappearing while new ones are still forming. Buildings remain physically present even as their meaning changes. People remain in the same streets while their relationships to one another are being reorganized. Sergio’s inability to adapt therefore becomes almost architectural. He occupies spaces belonging to a social world that is vanishing around him.
Leo Brouwer’s music contributes another dimension by refusing the safe emotional cues conventional film scores often provide. The music can create tension, distance or irony rather than simply instructing us how to feel. This is consistent with the entire approach of the film. Gutiérrez Alea refuses to make the audience comfortable.
He does not give us a hero to admire uncritically. He gives us someone to examine. That difference is central to the greatness of the film. One of the most interesting aspects of Memories of Underdevelopment is that it was produced inside the revolutionary film institution, ICAIC, yet remains willing to create such an ambiguous central character. This tells us something important about the artistic confidence of Cuban cinema during the 1960s.
A weaker national cinema might have created only exemplary revolutionary protagonists. Cuban cinema at its best was more ambitious. It understood that examining a society through contradiction could reveal more than simply presenting ideal behavior. Sergio’s existence is useful precisely because he allows Gutiérrez Alea to examine a section of Cuban society that the Revolution had displaced politically but had not magically erased psychologically.
The habits of class survive after the economic structure supporting them begins to disappear. A person may lose privilege without immediately losing the worldview created by privilege. This is one reason Sergio remains relevant far beyond Cuba. Every social transformation leaves behind people whose emotional development moves more slowly than history. Political systems can change rapidly. Human beings usually change much more slowly. The film also raises an important question about what development actually means.
Economic development alone does not create mature human beings. Education does not guarantee empathy. Cultural sophistication does not automatically produce moral courage. Sergio possesses several qualities that conventional society might associate with development, yet he remains emotionally incapable of participating fully in life.
The Revolution becomes a kind of test he cannot pass because it requires something his books and intellectual confidence have never taught him: involvement with other people. This is what makes the final movement of the film so effective. As the confrontation between Cuba and the United States intensifies, Sergio’s private detachment becomes increasingly absurd.
History is approaching with enormous force. The possibility of nuclear war hangs over the island. At that point, the luxury of remaining merely an observer begins to disappear. For me, this is where the film’s political meaning becomes most powerful. Cuba has made a choice to determine its own future after decades in which the United States exercised enormous influence over the island. Whatever uncertainty remains inside the new society, the country itself has committed to a direction.

Sergio cannot. The contrast is devastating. A nation that foreign powers once treated as dependent has decided to act independently, while the supposedly independent intellectual remains trapped by his own inability to act. This inversion gives the title another meaning. The underdeveloped character may not be the society Sergio criticizes. It may be the man incapable of growing with it.
More than half a century later, Memories of Underdevelopment remains one of the great achievements of Cuban cinema because Gutiérrez Alea trusted the Revolution enough to make a film filled with ambiguity. He did not need to pretend that every person welcomed change or that revolutionary transformation immediately created perfect human beings. He understood that real change is more interesting. Some people move forward. Some resist. Some leave. Some remain physically while never emotionally arriving. Sergio belongs to the last group. His tragedy is not that the Revolution destroys his world. His tragedy is that once the old world disappears, he discovers how little he has created inside himself to replace it.
That is why the film remains more than a historical portrait of Cuba in the early 1960s. It is a study of a type of person who exists in every period of profound change, the intelligent observer who understands everything except his own responsibility. Tomás Gutiérrez Alea created this character without hatred and without sentimentality, which allows Sergio to remain fascinating even when his failures become impossible to ignore.
The Revolution moves through Havana while Sergio continues looking from his window. The country is attempting to overcome the underdevelopment imposed by centuries of colonialism, inequality and foreign domination, while Sergio remains imprisoned by another kind of underdevelopment that no government can correct for him. That final transformation has to come from within, and Memories of Underdevelopment understands that Sergio may never be capable of making it.

