European filmmakers are struggling to sustain their careers despite the considerable time and resources invested in bringing their projects to the screen. This was the central message of “Fair Pay, Stronger Stories: Making Directing Careers Sustainable”, a panel held at Industry@Tallinn & Baltic Event on 16 November, bringing together representatives from Estonia, the Netherlands and Poland to discuss remuneration, collective bargaining and authors’ rights.
Moderated by Federation of European Screen Directors (FERA) chair Bill Anderson, the session featured Estonian filmmaker Liina Triškina-Vanhatalo, Dutch Directors Guild chairman Martijn Winkler and Polish director Katarzyna Klimkiewicz.
Triškina-Vanhatalo presented the findings of a new survey conducted by the Estonian Film Directors’ Guild (EFG) and the Estonian Association of Audiovisual Authors (EAAL), examining 15 feature films produced over the past five years with substantial public funding. The figures painted a troubling picture. Directing a feature requires a median of 596 eight-hour working days, equivalent to approximately two-and-a-half working years, while shooting represents less than 15% of the workload in most cases. Nevertheless, directors’ median earnings amount to just €6.90 net per hour, compared with approximately €5 for the national minimum wage and €14 for the median cultural worker.
The survey also exposed structural weaknesses in contractual arrangements. In ten of the 15 films examined, the director initiated the project, while eight directors also served as screenwriters. However, contracts frequently fail to distinguish between writing and directing fees, or between remuneration for work and payments for rights.
Under the prevailing buyout model, economic rights, including future uses and derivative works, are transferred to producers without geographical or time limitations. Furthermore, larger production budgets do not necessarily translate into higher directors’ fees, while accepting lower remuneration does not guarantee greater participation in eventual sales profits.
These difficulties are compounded by Estonia’s limited funding resources. Approximately €9.4 million were available for film financing in 2025, with the Estonian Film Institute supporting four or five medium-budget features annually, alongside documentaries and animation.
“Is this a very sustainable way to go?” Triškina-Vanhatalo asked, arguing that responsibility for filmmakers’ livelihoods should be shared among creators, producers and public institutions.
Winkler offered a contrasting perspective from the Netherlands, where years of research and negotiations have produced a comprehensive fair-pay framework. Beginning in September 2022, representatives of 19 organisations, including guilds, producers, broadcasters and unions, worked together to establish common definitions, professional classifications and minimum remuneration. The process involved creating a glossary of 383 terms, assessing responsibilities across 13 departments and comparing audiovisual occupations with established salary scales in theatre, dance and broadcasting.
A 74% supplement was added to comparable salaried rates to account for freelancers’ pensions, insurance, holiday entitlements and periods between assignments. The resulting 2026 minimum hourly rates range from €29.16 to €66.64, excluding VAT, with directors classified at levels J (€57.80) or K (€66.64), depending on the production.
These benchmarks, available through the online Filmwerkwijs calculator, are now linked to Dutch public funding requirements. Importantly, remuneration for authors’ rights remains separate from payments for hours worked. “It’s not a luxury when you talk about fair pay; it’s a floor,” Winkler underscored.
However, introducing minimum remuneration has also forced difficult decisions to be made about production volumes. Winkler explained that some broadcasters have reduced their output, rather than continuing to finance projects through underpaid labour, while additional government funding has helped accommodate the new requirements.
Klimkiewicz discussed Poland’s campaign to secure royalties from streaming platforms, demonstrating how filmmakers can mobilise collectively to influence legislation and challenge powerful international companies. “This is not extra money; this is their last payment for our work,” she argued, insisting that royalties constitute an integral part of creators’ remuneration, rather than an optional bonus. She also highlighted ongoing efforts to strengthen social protection for freelancers and described a development scheme supported by filmmakers’ royalties that offers emerging creators approximately €500 per month.
During the Q&A, the discussion also touched upon Ireland’s Basic Income for the Arts scheme, raised as a possible model for supporting filmmakers between projects. Anderson praised the Irish experiment, pointing to its reported economic benefits and suggesting that direct income support could offer greater stability to creative professionals. Klimkiewicz, meanwhile, underlined Poland’s efforts to introduce social security protections for freelancers, including government contributions for lower-paid professionals, although the proposed measures have yet to complete the legislative process.
The discussion eventually turned to international co-productions, where disparities between national pay scales remain unresolved, and the considerable unpaid development work required before projects secure financing.
For Anderson, the underlying issue extends beyond wages: without sustainable professional careers, European cinema risks losing the titular “stronger stories” that underpin its cultural diversity. Fair pay, the speakers agreed, is not simply a question of financial justice, but a prerequisite for stronger films and a healthier audiovisual sector.

