CineMonth – Cuban Cinema – Reviews 2

Humberto Solás’s Lucía is one of those rare films in which the history of a country and the emotional lives of its people become impossible to separate. Made in 1968, the film is divided into three episodes, each centered on a different woman named Lucía and each set during a decisive period of Cuban history. The first takes place in 1895 during the struggle for independence from Spain, the second in the 1930s during resistance to the dictatorship of Gerardo Machado, and the third after the Revolution, when a new society is being built while old habits, particularly those surrounding male domination, have not yet disappeared. Solás uses these three women not merely as witnesses to history but as people whose most intimate relationships are shaped by the political world around them.

What gives Lucía its extraordinary power is that Solás never treats history as something existing outside ordinary life. War enters love. Political repression enters marriage. Revolution enters the home. The three women live in different social classes and different historical periods, yet all of them discover that personal freedom cannot be separated from the society in which they live. Their emotional choices are therefore never completely private, and the men they love often carry the values and contradictions of the historical period into the relationship.

The first Lucía, played by Raquel Revuelta, belongs to the Cuban upper class during the final years of Spanish colonial rule. She lives within a protected social environment while the independence war is taking place around her, and at first there seems to be a distance between her privileged life and the violence shaping the future of Cuba. That distance disappears when she falls in love with Rafael, a Spanish man whose attraction to her gradually reveals another purpose.

The romance becomes tragic because Lucía’s emotional vulnerability is used against the struggle for Cuban independence. Rafael gains her confidence and through that intimacy acquires information that contributes to disaster. Solás transforms what might have been a conventional story of romantic betrayal into something much larger because Lucía’s personal tragedy becomes inseparable from colonial power. Her trust in a man and Cuba’s struggle against Spain become part of the same wound.

The visual style of this first section is extraordinarily aggressive. Jorge Herrera’s black-and-white cinematography pushes contrast toward extremes, while handheld movement and distorted close-ups create an atmosphere in which emotional and political violence seem to infect the image itself. Solás does not photograph the nineteenth century as a polished historical reconstruction. He makes it feverish and unstable, allowing the style to reflect a society approaching the end of colonial rule.

The battle sequences possess an almost physical brutality. Bodies collide, the camera appears to struggle for position, and the romantic elegance surrounding Lucía’s social world gives way to confusion and violence. This contrast is essential because the privileged class has been able to imagine itself at some distance from the war, but history eventually enters that protected world with devastating force.

Raquel Revuelta gives Lucía an emotional intensity that suits the operatic quality of the episode. Her character begins within the restrictions of class and respectability, but love creates the illusion that she might escape them. The tragedy is that the man who appears to offer freedom instead uses the intimacy between them as another instrument of colonial conflict.

There is a painful irony in this because Lucía believes she is acting as an individual at precisely the moment when history demonstrates how difficult individual freedom can be under colonial domination. Her private life cannot remain private because the country itself is fighting to determine who controls its future.

The second episode moves to the 1930s and changes style almost completely. Eslinda Núñez plays a younger Lucía belonging to the bourgeoisie during the political struggle against Machado. Unlike the first Lucía, she becomes actively involved in revolutionary politics and enters a relationship with Aldo, a young man committed to the opposition movement.

Here love and political commitment initially seem to move in the same direction. Lucía is not manipulated into history; she chooses to participate in it. Her relationship with Aldo is connected to a shared hope that Cuba can become something different, and their political struggle creates an intimacy based on risk as well as desire.

Yet Solás refuses to turn political commitment into romantic certainty. The defeat of one dictator does not automatically produce the society for which people fought, and revolutionary enthusiasm can be followed by disappointment when political change fails to go far enough. The second episode therefore becomes a story about the difference between participating in a struggle and living with what comes afterward.

This is one of the film’s most intelligent historical observations. Political movements often possess enormous emotional clarity while the enemy remains obvious. People know what they oppose and can imagine that removing it will allow a different future to begin. The difficult period comes afterward, when the compromises, disappointments and unfinished work of political transformation become visible.

Lucía and Aldo experience that transition personally. Their love belongs to the energy of resistance, but love alone cannot protect them from the frustrations of a political process that does not fulfill everything they had imagined.

Solás changes the visual language to match this different historical period. The extreme expressionism of the first episode gives way to a more controlled form of realism, although the images retain a strong emotional quality. The second Lucía inhabits a society that appears more modern than the colonial world of 1895, but the political instability beneath that surface remains powerful.

Eslinda Núñez creates a Lucía who is more politically conscious than the woman in the first episode, yet awareness does not free her from emotional suffering. This is important because Solás refuses the easy idea that political participation automatically creates personal liberation. A woman can fight courageously against dictatorship while still confronting unequal expectations inside relationships and society.

The third episode is where Lucía becomes especially important in understanding Solás’s relationship with the Revolution. Set after 1959, it moves away from the tragic atmosphere of the earlier sections and introduces much more humor. Adela Legrá plays a rural woman who has benefited from the revolutionary transformation of Cuban society but finds herself married to Tomás, a man whose understanding of marriage belongs to an older patriarchal world.

This conflict allows Solás to examine one of the most difficult questions facing any revolution: how quickly can political institutions change compared with human behavior? A government can pass laws, expand education and create new economic relationships, but attitudes learned over generations cannot be abolished by decree.

Tomás may live inside revolutionary Cuba, but his idea of marriage is profoundly possessive. He wants Lucía to remain at home, separated from other people and dependent upon him. His jealousy becomes almost comic because it belongs so obviously to a world the Revolution is attempting to leave behind.

The comedy is important because Solás does not treat Tomás as a monster. He is ridiculous, frustrating and deeply shaped by machismo, but he is also capable of affection. This complexity makes the episode stronger because patriarchy does not survive only through obviously evil men. It survives through ordinary behavior accepted for so long that people may barely recognize it as oppressive.

Lucía’s struggle therefore becomes part of the unfinished work of the Revolution. She has gained opportunities that women of earlier generations did not possess, but those opportunities have meaning only if she can exercise them inside everyday life.

The famous conflict over work becomes central. Tomás wants to control whether Lucía can work outside the home, while Lucía increasingly understands that economic and social participation are essential to her independence. Their marriage becomes a small battlefield where two different ideas of post-revolutionary Cuba confront each other.

This is where I find Solás particularly perceptive. He clearly believes in the transformation that has taken place after 1959, but he also understands that a revolution proves itself not only through political institutions but through what happens between two people inside a house. If a woman gains rights publicly while remaining privately controlled by her husband, liberation remains incomplete.

Solás expresses this idea through humor rather than ideological speeches, and that choice gives the episode enormous warmth. Tomás repeatedly attempts to impose authority while Lucía resists him, and the conflict becomes both funny and serious because their love remains present inside the struggle.

Adela Legrá is wonderful in this section because her Lucía possesses an instinctive strength that does not need intellectual explanation. She is not a political theorist, but she understands when something is unfair. Her rebellion begins from lived experience rather than abstract ideology, which makes her one of the film’s most immediately sympathetic characters.

The change in cinematography is again important. The third episode is brighter and more open, and the camera moves closer to the characters. The harsh contrasts of the colonial episode have given way to a visual world containing more light, movement and intimacy. The society is not perfect, but the images themselves suggest possibility.

Solás does not use this brightness to pretend that conflict has disappeared. Instead, the visual openness reflects a society in which conflict can now take another form. Lucía no longer struggles against colonial domination or dictatorship in the same way as the women before her. Her struggle concerns the meaning of equality inside a society that has already committed itself to revolutionary transformation.

This progression gives the three-part structure its unity. The first Lucía lives under colonialism and is destroyed by a relationship shaped by foreign domination. The second lives under the unstable republic and actively joins a political struggle that remains incomplete. The third lives after the Revolution and confronts the remaining patriarchal habits that political transformation has not yet eliminated. Together, the three women allow Solás to examine liberation not as one event but as a long historical process.

This is why the film remains so much more interesting than a conventional historical epic. Most epics organize history around battles, political leaders and major public events. Solás gives us those forces through women whose experiences might have been treated as secondary by traditional history. Love becomes historical evidence. Marriage becomes political. Jealousy becomes part of the question of liberation. A woman’s ability to work becomes a measure of social change. This perspective was remarkably ambitious in 1968, and it remains powerful today.

Solás himself insisted that Lucía should not be reduced simply to a film about women, and I understand what he meant. The women are the means through which he examines Cuban society as a whole. At the same time, choosing women as the center changes how that history is understood because political transformation is measured through areas that conventional historical cinema often ignores.

A government can declare independence, but what does independence mean to a woman whose life remains controlled by men? A dictatorship can fall, but what happens to the people who risked their lives when political reality fails to match their hopes? A revolution can transform society, but how deeply has it succeeded if old forms of domination continue inside the family? These questions give Lucía its lasting importance.

The performances of the three actresses are essential because each Lucía belongs to a different cinematic world. Raquel Revuelta gives the first episode tragic grandeur, Eslinda Núñez brings intelligence and political awakening to the second, while Adela Legrá gives the third humor, spontaneity and determination.

They are not different versions of the same woman. They are different Cuban women connected by a name and by the long struggle for liberation. The film’s nearly three-hour running time allows each period to develop enough emotional weight that the characters never feel like illustrations in a history book. Solás gives us time to live with them before history changes their lives.

This patience is one reason the final effect becomes so powerful. By the third episode, the audience has already experienced colonial violence and republican disappointment, which means the Revolution appears not as an isolated political event but as the culmination of struggles extending across generations.

This historical continuity is essential to the film’s point of view. The Cuban Revolution did not begin Cuba’s desire for independence. It inherited it. The people fighting Spain in the nineteenth century, those struggling against dictatorship and foreign domination during the republic, and the revolutionary generation of the twentieth century belong to different political circumstances, but Solás places them inside the same long search for national and personal freedom.

The three Lucías embody that continuity. Their experiences also demonstrate that women paid the emotional price of those historical struggles while frequently receiving less attention in official histories. Solás corrects that imbalance without turning the women into saints. They make mistakes. They fall in love with the wrong men. They experience jealousy, fear and confusion. Their humanity is what makes their historical significance believable.

This is particularly important in the first episode, where Lucía’s mistake has devastating consequences. Solás does not condemn her for being emotionally vulnerable. Colonial conflict has created a situation in which intimacy itself can become dangerous. The second Lucía has greater political consciousness, but consciousness cannot protect her from disappointment.

The third has greater social freedom, but freedom still requires daily struggle. Each generation therefore advances while inheriting something unresolved from the one before it. That is perhaps the most revolutionary idea in the film. Progress exists, but it is not automatic.

The Revolution has opened possibilities that earlier Lucías could not imagine, yet Solás does not suggest that history has ended. The final woman must continue the struggle in another form because liberation changes its meaning as society changes.

This attitude is one of the things I admire most about the great Cuban films of the 1960s. They were confident enough in the Revolution to examine what remained unfinished. A weak political cinema needs perfection. A strong political cinema can tolerate contradiction. Lucía belongs completely to the second tradition.

The final section is optimistic precisely because conflict remains possible. Lucía can argue with Tomás because she now possesses a social position from which resistance has meaning. She can work, challenge him and insist upon another kind of relationship because the world around her has begun making those choices possible.

The distance between her and the first Lucía is enormous. One woman is destroyed within a colonial society whose political future is controlled from abroad. Another participates in the fight against dictatorship but encounters the limits of incomplete change.

The third lives in a country that has asserted its independence and now confronts the deeper work of transforming relationships between its own people. Solás makes this historical progression visible without ever turning the film into a lecture. He trusts faces, bodies, landscapes, arguments and love affairs to carry history. That is cinema.

More than fifty years after Lucía was made, its visual ambition remains astonishing. Each episode could almost have been directed as a separate film, yet the changes in style become part of the larger meaning. The camera itself seems to travel through Cuban history, moving from the violence and darkness of colonialism toward a brighter and more intimate revolutionary present.

The film has since been restored and rediscovered internationally, allowing new audiences to experience the richness of Jorge Herrera’s cinematography and Nelson Rodríguez’s editing. That renewed attention is deserved because Lucía should never be regarded only as an important Cuban film.

It belongs among the major works of world cinema produced during the extraordinary filmmaking period of the 1960s. What makes it unmistakably Cuban is also what allows it to travel. The struggle against colonialism is Cuban, but the emotional cost of domination can be understood anywhere. The political disappointment of the 1930s belongs to Cuban history, but every society knows the distance that can appear between revolutionary hope and political reality.

The conflict between Lucía and Tomás emerges from post-revolutionary Cuba, but women throughout the world understand the struggle between legal equality and private male control. Solás begins with Cuba and reaches something universal without sacrificing a single part of the film’s national identity. For me, Lucía ultimately succeeds because it understands that the history of liberation cannot be written only through the men who lead armies and governments. It must also be seen through the people whose private lives change when political structures change.

Humberto Solás gives us three women and asks us to look at Cuba through their eyes. Across seventy years of history, each Lucía lives with more possibility than the woman who came before her, yet each discovers another barrier that must be overcome. That movement from one generation to another gives the film its hope.

Cuban history in Lucía is not presented as a straight road toward perfection. It is a long struggle in which every achievement creates the possibility of recognizing the next injustice more clearly. By the time we reach the third Lucía, Cuba has finally escaped colonial rule, dictatorship and the overwhelming foreign domination that shaped so much of its earlier history. The remaining struggle has moved inside the society and even inside the home.

For Solás, that does not diminish the Revolution. It demonstrates how much more the Revolution has made possible. The first Lucía could barely imagine controlling her own destiny. The last Lucía is already demanding it. Between those two women lies nearly a century of Cuban history, and Humberto Solás turns that history into one of the most powerful films ever made about the meaning of liberation.

Share.

Comments are closed.